Adaptation of Outcome-Based Education System in Pakistan for Engineering Disciplines and its Critical Evaluation
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53560/PPASA(60-1)773Keywords:
Outcome Based Education, Pakistan’s Educational Reforms, Program Education Objectives, Program Learning ObjectivesAbstract
Pakistan has become a part of the Washington Accord in 2017 and started making reforms in its education sector. Outcome-Based Education (OBE) has been emphasized by Pakistan Engineering Council (PEC) for the accreditation of all engineering degree programs. This paper presents some basic literature on the existing educational models in the world and the Outcome Based Education-OBE structure that has been implemented in Pakistan yet. Pakistan has successfully designed the Program Education Objectives (PEOs) and Program Learning Objectives (PLOs) for the academic sector. PEOs are the mission/vision statements that define the career and professional goals which the program is preparing students to achieve. PLOs are the quantifiable statements that define the knowledge and skills expertise of the students upon graduation ceremony. A survey has been conducted by employers to assess the skill level of fresh graduates against 12 PLOs of the OBE system in Pakistan. Of these, the PLOs related to four measurable statements namely: (i) Problem Analysis, (ii) Design of Solutions, (iii) Investigation, and (iv) Environment & Sustainability are found underperformance as surveyed from the industry sector following the performance of freshly graduated students. The survey also includes the Key Performance Indicator (KPI) evaluation of faculty members both from the department heads and the students too. This result shows underperformance of 15 % of the teaching faculty as per prescribed grading ranges. However, the OBE faces some difficulties as well and unfortunately, there are not so many graduates who entered into the industry after learning from OBE. It will, therefore, take some time to deliver the results of OBE implementation in Pakistan. Furthermore, some other education reforms from around the globe have been presented in this paper and some suggestions have been provided.
References
S.M. Rahman. Relationship among GDP, per capita GDP, literacy rate, and unemployment rate. British Journal of Arts and Social Sciences 14(2): 169-177 (2013).
United Nation International Children’s Emergency Funds, UNICEF. https://www.unicef.org/education (Accessed on 18.12.2021).
Innovative School Networks, ISN. https://www.innovativeschoolsnetwork.com/resources/pages/education-models (Accessed on 27.12.2021).
P.J. William. STEM Education: proceed with caution. Design and Technology Education: An International Journal 16(1): 26-35 (2011).
B. Condliffe, J. Quint, M.G. Visher, M.R. Bangser, S. Drohojowska, L. Saco, and E. Nelson. Projectbased learning: A literature review. MDRC: Working Paper. https://www.mdrc.org/publication/project-based-learning (Accessed on 22.05.2023).
M.S. Arman, S. Rahman, S. Surat, and A.Y.A Bakar. Connecting neuroscience and education: Insight from neuroscience findings for better instructional learning. Journal for the Education of Gifted Young Scientist 7(2): 341-352 (2019).
L. Cornish. Multiage classes - What’s in a name? Journal of Multiage Education 4(2): 7-11 (2010).
International Engineering Alliance: Washington Accord. https://www.ieagreements.org/accords/washington (Accessed on 30.12.2021).
The Connecticut General Assembly, CTG. https://cga.ct.gov/PS94/rpt%5Colr%5Chtm/94-R-0290.html (Accessed on 23.12.2021).
www.k12academics.com (Accessed on 01.01.2022).
H.M. Asim, A. Vaz, A. Ahmed, and S. Samreen. Review on outcome-based education and factors that impact student learning outcomes in the tertiary education system. International Education Studies 14(2): 1-11 (2021).
R. Katawazai. Implementing outcome-based education and student-centered learning in Afghan public universities: The current practice and challenges. Heliyon 7(5): 16 (2021).
T. Oroszi. Competency-based education. Creative Education 11(11): 2467-2476 (2020).
N.O. Sullivan, and A. Bruce. Teaching and learning in competency-based education. In: 5th International Conference on e-Learning. Elearning, Serbia (2014).
J.A. Raelin. A model of work-based learning. Organization Science 8(6): 563-578 (1997).
C. Stasz, and D.J. BreweR. Work-Based Learning: Student Perspectives on Quality and Links to School. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 20(1): 31–46 (1998).
Pakistan Engineering Council. https://www.pec.org.pk/ (Accessed on 01.01.2022).
K. Mahmood, K.M. Khan, K.S. Khan, and S. Kiani. Implementation of outcome-based education in Pakistan: A step towards Washington Accord. In: IEEE 7th international conference on engineering education, ICEED: 166-170. IEEE (2015).
J.K. Estell. Streamlining the assessment process with the faculty course assessment report. International Journal of Engineering Education 25(5): 941-951 (2009).
M.M.U. Faiz, U. Bin Mansoor, S.M. Asad, and K. Mahmood. Using faculty course assessment report for the assessment of an associate degree course in engineering technology program. In: 6th International Conference on Engineering Education, ICEED: 73-78. IEEE (2014).
A. Manzoor, H. Aziz, M. Jahanzaib, A. Wasim, and S. Hussain. Transformational model for engineering education from content based to outcome-based education. International Journal of Continuing Engineering Education and Life-Long Learning 27(4): 266 (2017).
A. Mirza, and S. Javed. An effective and efficient implementation of the OBE framework within a constrained Pakistani Environment to attain desired learning outcomes. Sir Syed University Research Journal of Engineering & Technology 12(1): 7 (2022).
M. Kamran, B.U. Nisa, M.R. Fazal, M.I. Abid, and I. Abid. Implementation of the outcome-based education system in engineering programs for Pakistan Engineering Council accreditation under Washington accord signatory. Science International (Lahore) 32(2): 197-206 (2020).
K. Mahmood. Practicing outcome-based education in Pakistan universities: A step towards globalization. Pakistan Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research 4(2): 189-201 (2021).
DHA Suffa University, DSU. https://www.dsu.edu.pk/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/obe_students_manual.pdf (Accessed on 04.01.2022).
Sir Syed University of Engineering and TechnologyKarachi (SSUET) https://www.ssuet.edu.pk/qec-introduction/ssuet-policies/
(Accessed on 22.10.2022).
https://ppd.neduet.edu.pk/sites/default/files/Introduction%20to%20Outcome%20Based%20Education%20(OBE)%20for%20students_3.pdf (Accessed on 05.04.2023)
A. Dewani, S. Bhatti, and M.A. Memon. Analysis of Outcome-based educational model in Engineering Education with preliminary Findings. International Journal of Advanced Culture Technology 10(1): 1-9 (2022).
