Optimized Processing Techniques for Enhancing Fillet Yield from Low-Value Fish in Lamongan, East Java, Indonesia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53560/PPASB(62-2)957Keywords:
Chemical Composition, Enzymatic Processing, Fillet Yield, Papain Enzyme, Trash FishAbstract
Fishing activities often yield a bycatch of low-value fish (trash fish) that typically remains underutilized. This study aimed to identify the most effective preparation technique to improve the physical and chemical quality of fillets from three types of trash fish: Orangefin ponyfish (Leiognathus bindus), chacunda gizzard shad (Anodontostoma chacunda), and sardine (Sardinella fimbriata). A Randomized Block Design (RBD) was used with two factors: fish species and preparation technique, including mechanical treatment, blanching, immersion in 1% acetic acid, and immersion in 1% papain enzyme. Data were statistically analyzed and presented descriptively in tables and graphs. The results showed that treatment with 1% papain enzyme yielded the highest fillet yield (47.5% to 63.2%) and the shortest processing time. Additionally, the enzymatic treatment produced fillets with favorable chemical characteristics: moisture content (77.46% to 80.13%), protein (7.39% to 9.29%), fat (8.01% to 9.49%), and ash (1.55% to 2.83%). This study demonstrates that enzymatic preparation is effective in enhancing both the efficiency and quality of trash fish fillets, potentially increasing the added value of fishermen's catches.
References
1. A.I. Fauzi, N. Azizah, E. Yati, A.T. Atmojo, A. Rohman, R. Putra, M.A.E. Rahadianto, D. Ramadhanti, N.H. Ardani, B.F. Robbani, M.U. Nuha, A.M.P. Perdana, A.D. Sakti, M. Aufaristama, and K. Wikantika. Potential loss of ecosystem service value due to vessel activity expansion in Indonesian marine protected areas. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information 12(2): 75 (2023).
2. Estradivari, I. Kartika, D.S. Adhuri, L. Adrianto, F. Agung, G.N. Ahmadia, S. Bejarano, S.J. Campbell, F.R. Fachri, H. Kushardanto, C. Marlessy, B. Pane, O. Puebla, R.C. Purnama, I.W.V. Santiadji, W. Suherfian, M. Tillah, H. Widodo, C. Wild, and S.C.A. Ferse. Prospective ecological contributions of potential marine OECMs and MPAs to enhance marine conservation in Indonesia. Ocean and Coastal Management 258: 1-15 (2024).
3. M. Larasati. Raw material management for frozen Parupeneus heptacanthus fillet products at PT Baruna, Lamongan, East Java. Genbinesia Journal of Biology 3(3): 90-104 (2024).
4. M.S.A. Ningsih, Prayogo, and A.M. Sahidu. Vaname shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) post-harvest marketing analysis in traditional pond systems at Turi District, Lamongan, East Java, Indonesia. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 441: 012034 (2020).
5. M.A. Nugraha, and Rozi. The effect of giving commercial feed, beloso trash fish (Saurida tumbil), kurisi trash fish (Nemipterus nematophorus), and mixed trash fish on growth of cantang grouper (Epinephelus fuscoguttatus-lanceolatus) in floating net cage. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 441: 012069 (2020).
6. R. Raeesi, B. Shabanpour, and P. Pourashouri. Use of fish waste to silage preparation and its application in animal nutrition. Online Journal of Animal and Feed Research. 13(2): 79-88 (2023).
7. L.A. Ramírez, B.S. Romero, G. Poss, J.E.S. Hernández, H.M.N. Iqbal, R.P. Saldívar, A.D. Bonaccorso, and E.M.M. Martínez. Sustainable production of biofuels and bioderivatives from aquaculture and marine waste. Frontiers in Chemical Engineering 4: 1072761 (2023).
8. S.S. Harsono, R.H. Setyobudi, and T. Zeemanid. Biodiesel production from waste fish for zero waste concept in remote area of Eastern of Java, Indonesia. Jurnal Teknologi 78: 215-219 (2016).
9. D.S. Akhila, P. Ashwath, K.G. Manjunatha, S.D. Akshay, V.K.R. Surasani, F.R. Sofi, K. Saba, P.K. Dara, Y. Ozogul, and F. Ozogul. Seafood processing waste as a source of functional components: Extraction and applications for various food and non-food systems. Trends in Food Science & Technology 145: 104348.(2024).
10. C. Fuentes, S. Verdú, R. Grau, J.M. Barat, and A. Fuentes. Impact of raw material and enzyme type on the physico-chemical and functional properties of fish by-products hydrolysates. LWT- Food Science and Technology 201: 116247 (2024).
11. Md. Selim Reza, S.M.R. Islam, Md.R. Hasan, D. Karmakar, F. Mim, Md.A.A. Shaikh, and Md.R. Karim. Unlocking critical nutritional potential: A comprehensive analysis of small indigenous fishes in Bangladesh and the development of ready-to-use fish products as balanced food. Future Foods 9: 100346 (2024).
12. J. Burlakovs, Z. Vincevica-Gaile, V. Bisters, W. Hogland, M. Kriipsalu, I. Zekker, R.H. Setyobudi, Y. Jani, and O. Anne. Application of anaerobic digestion for biogas and methane production from fresh beach-cast biomass. European Association of Geoscientists & Engineers 2022: 1-5 (2022).
13. C. Anam, M.F.M. Atoum, N. Harini, D. Damat, R.H. Setyobudi, A. Wahyudi, A.D. Pamujiati, N. Kuswardhani, Y. Witono, R. Tonda, H. Prasetyo, I. Ekawati, E.D. Purbajanti, Z. Vincēviča-Gaile, T. Liblik, A. Fauzi, H. Hadinoto, N.S. Sebayang, E. Suhesti, A. Putri, and F. Munsif. Chemical and functional properties of myofibrillar protein from selected species of trash fish. Jordan Journal of Biological Sciences 16(2): 267-277 (2023).
14. C. Anam, N. Harini, D. Damat, R.H. Setyobudi, I. Ekawati, T. Liblik, E.D. Purbajanti, H. Bernedektus, L.M. Souripet, A. Fauzi, A.R. Farzana, R. Tonda, I. Iswahyudi, A. Amiroh, M. Qibtiyah, D.E. Kusumawati, I. Istiqomah, and E. Hamidah. Functional characteristics of trash fish in Lamongan regency, East Java, Indonesia. E3S Web of Conferences 432: 00007 (2023).
15. C. Anam, N. Harini, D. Damat, A. Wahyudi, Y. Witono, N. Kuswardhani, M.A.S. Azar, O. Anne, and D. Rachmawati. Potential analysis of low economic value fish in Lamongan regency, East Java, Indonesia. E3S Web of Conferences 226: 00011 (2021).
16. N.D. Rahayu, L. Sulmartiwi, G. Mahasri, Muntalim, B. Angwarmas, and G.D. Pamenang. Inventory of ectoparasite helminth on the hybrid grouper (Epinephelus fuscoguttatus x Epinephelus lanceolatus) from traditional ponds in the kampung kerapu Lamongan East Java Indonesia, IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 441: 012095 (2020).
17. E.I. Jimenez-Ruiz, A.N. Maeda-Martínez, V.M. Ocaño-Higuera, M.T. Sumaya-Martinez, L.M. Sanchez-Herrera, O.A. Fregoso-Aguirre, J.E. Rincones-López, and Y.A. Palomino-Hermosillo. Shelf life of fresh fillets from eviscerated farmed tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) handled at different pre-filleting times. Journal of Food Processing and Preservation 44: e14529 (2020).
18. K. Adrah, and R. Tahergorabi. Ready-to-eat products elaborated with mechanically separated fish meat from waste processing. In: Sustainable Fish Production and Processing. C.M. Galanakis (Ed.). Academic Press pp. 227-257 (2022).
19. D.T. Hopkins, F. Berrue’, Z. Khiari, and K.A. Hawboldt. Valorization of fisheries by-products via enzymatic protein hydrolysis: A review of operating conditions, process design, and future trends. Process Biochemistry. 149: 306-320 (2025).
20. I. Akbariwati. Karakteristik Fisik, Kimia, dan Fungsional Fillet Ikan Wader (Rasbora jacobsoni), Bader (Puintius javanicus), dan Patin (Pangasius hypophthalmus) Akibat dari Perbedaan Preparasi.[Physical, Chemical and functional characteristics of wader (Rasbora jacobsoni), Bader (Puintius javanicus) and Patin (Pangasius hypophthalmus) fish fillets as a result of differences in preparation techniques]. Undergraduate Thesis, Universitas Jember (2015). [in Bahasa Indonesia].
21. J. Fu, Y. He, and F. Cheng. Intelligent cutting in fish processing: Efficient, high-quality, and safe production of fish products. Food and Bioprocess Technology 17: 828-849 (2023).
22. T.V.L. Nguyen, T. Vo, T. D. Lam, and L.G. Bach. Water blanching conditions on the quality of green asparagus butt segment (Asparagus officinalis L.). Materials Today: Proceedings 18: 4799-4809 (2019).
23. T. Moniharapon, F. Pattipeilohy, D. L. Moniharapon, and R. B. D. D. Sormin. The effect of gradual salt soaking and atung (Parinarium glaberimum, Hassk) on the yield and quality of dry salted bony flying fish (Cypselurus oxycephalus). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 339: 012051 (2019).
24. Y.P Arisky, S. Supriyanto, and M. Fakhry. The effect of using bromelain and papain enzymes on the quality of pure fish oil from Milkfish silage (Chanos chanos). Scientific Journal of Fisheries and Marine Sciences 13(2): 233-242 (2021).
25. O.E. Urgessa1, D. D. Itana, and T. O. Raga. Extraction of papain from papaya (Carica papaya L.) fruit latex and its application in transforming tannery raw trimming. Ethiopian Journal of Science and Sustainable Development 6(2): 22-32 (2019)
26. J. C. Gukowsky, T. Xie, S. Gao, Y. Qu, and L. He. Rapid identification of artificial and natural food colorants with surface enhanced raman spectroscopy. Food Control 92: 267-275 (2018).
27. W.T. Eden and C.O. Rumambarsari. Proximate analysis of soybean and red beans cookies according to the Indonesian national standard. Journal of Physics: Conference Series 1567: 022033 (2020).
28. J.M. Elliott. Body composition of brown trout (Salmo trutta L.) in relation to temperature and ration size. Journal of Animal Ecology 45(1): 273-289 (1976).
29. M.S. Caulton and E. Bursell. The relationship between changes in condition and body composition in young Tilapia rendalli Boulenger. Journal of Fish Biology 11(2): 143-150 (1977).
30. A.H. Weatherley and H.S. Gill. Growth increases produced by bovine growth hormone in grass pickerel, Esox americanus vermiculatus (Le Sueur), and the underlying dynamics of muscle fiber growth. Aquaculture 65(1): 55-66 (1987).
31. P.G. Adinurani, R.H. Setyobudi, A, Nindita, S.K. Wahono, M. Maizirwan, A. Sasmito, Y.A. Nugroho and T, Liwang. Chaterization of Jatropha curcas Linn. capsule husk as feedstock for anaerobic digestion. Energy Procedia 65: 264-273 (2015).
32. B.A. Babalola, A.I. Akinwande, A.A. Otunba, G.E. Adebami, O. Babalola, and Ch. Nwufo. Therapeutic benefits of Carica papaya: A review on its pharmacological activities and characterization of papain. Arabian Journal of Chemistry 17: 105369 (2024).
33. W.O. Ribeiro, M.M. Ozaki, M. Santos, R.J.S. Castro, H.H. Sato, A.K.F.I. Camara, A.P. Rodríguez, P.C.B. Campagnol, M. Aparecida, and R. Pollonio. Evaluating different levels of papain as texture modifying agent in bovine meat loaf containing transglutaminase. Meat Science 198: 109112 (2023).
34. Z. Zhang, Y. Wu, Ch. Zhang, and F. Huang. Exploring how papaya juice improves meat tenderness and digestive characteristics in Wenchang chickens. Poultry Science 104: 104621 (2025).
35. J. Luo, M. Zhang, Y. Zeng, H. Guo, X. Wu, Z. Meng, and R. Yin. Structural and functional properties of protein hydrolysates from myofibrillar protein of crocodile (Crocodylus siamensis) meat. LWT-Food Science and Technology 196: 115862 (2024).
36. D. Damat, R.H. Setyobudi, J.S. Utomo, Z. Vincēviča-Gaile, A. Tain and D.D. Siskawardani. The characteristics and predicted of glycemic index of rice analogue from modified arrowroot starch (Maranta arundinaceae L.). Jordan Journal of Biological Sciences 14(3): 389-393 (2021).
37. M. Sterniša, C. Purgatorio, A. Paparella, J. Mraz, and S.S. Možina. Combination of rosemary extract and buffered vinegar inhibits Pseudomonas and Shewanella growth in common carp (Cyprinus carpio). Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 100(5): 2305-2312 (2020).
38. C.M. Harris and S.K. Williams. The antimicrobial properties of a vinegar-based ingredient on Salmonella Typhimurium and psychrotrophs inoculated in ground chicken breast meat and stored at 3±1 0C for 7 days. Journal of Applied Poultry Research 28(1): 118-123 (2019).
39. M. Laranjo, M.E. Potes, A. Gomes, J. Vestia, R. Garcia, M.J. Fernandes, M.J. Fraqueza, and M. Elias. Shelf-life extension and quality improvement of a Portuguese traditional ready-to-eat meat product with vinegar. International Journal of Food Science and Technology 54(1): 132-140 (2019).
40. D.V. Nkosi, J.L. Bekker, and L.C. Hoffman. The use of organic acids (Lactic and acetic) as a microbial decontaminant during the slaughter of meat animal species: A review. Foods 10(10): 2293 (2021).
41. K.M. Park, H.J. Kim, J.Y. Choi, and M. Koo. Antimicrobial effect of acetic acid, sodium hypochlorite, and thermal treatments against psychrotolerant bacillus cereus group isolated from lettuce (Lactuca sativa l.). Foods 10(9): 2165 (2021).
42. G.K.T.N. Lelwela, S.K.D. Wijesinghe, S.M.C. Himali, and E.D.N.S. Abeyrathne. Effect of selected wood smoke on physicochemical and sensory qualities of Tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus). Journal of Aquatic Food Product Technology 30(1): 85-94 (2021).
43. M. Saeed, S. ur Rahman, M.A. Shabbir, N. Khan, and A. Shakeel. Extraction and utilization of papaya extract as meat tenderizer and antimicrobial activity against Salmonella typhimurium. Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences 54(1): 153-159 (2017).
44. H. Hariyati, M. Mahendradatta, A.B. Tawali, and J. Langkong. Enzymatic hydrolysis of proteins from snakehead-fish (Channa striata). IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 885: 012015 (2020).
45. H. Wang, Q. Zhang, A.S. Mujumdar, X.M. Fang, J. Wang, Y.P. Pei, W. Wu, M. Zielinska, and H.W. Xiao. High-humidity hot air impingement blanching (HHAIB) efficiently inactivates enzymes, enhances extraction of phytochemicals and mitigates brown actions of chili pepper. Food Control 111: 107050 (2020).
46. S. Perveen, S. Akhtar, M. Qamar, W. Saeed, R. Suleman, M. Younis, T. Ismail, and T. Esatbeyoglu. The effect of Lactiplantibacillus plantarum fermentation and blanching on microbial population, nutrients, anti-nutrients and antioxidant properties of fresh and dried mature Moringa oleifera leaves. Journal of Agriculture and Food Research 18: 101366 (2024).
47. S. Biseniusa, H. Neuhausa, S. Effkemanna, O. Heemkena, E. Bartelta, T. Langb, E. Haunhorstc, and C. Kehrenberg. Composition of herring and cod fillets from the north and the baltic sea–detecting added water. Food Control 107: 106766 (2020).
48. V. Lal and M. Naeem. Proximate composition analysis of marine fish, Terapon jarbua, from Pakistan. Sarhad Journal of Agriculture 37(1): 290-295 (2021).
49. S.S. Chan, B. Rothb, M. Skarec, M. Hernarc, F. Jessend, T. Løvdalb, A.N. Jakobsena, and J. Lerfalla. Effect of chilling technologies on water holding properties and other quality parameters throughout the whole value chain: From whole fish to cold-smoked fillets of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Aquaculture 526: 735381 (2020).
50. S.M. Ibrahim, A.A. Elgnainy, N. Imam, A.H. Fadel, and A.S. Abouzied. Effect of gamma rays on nutritive value, and on occurrence of vibrio alginolyticus in fillets of puffer fish (Logocephalus sceleratus). Egyptian Journal of Aquatic Research 44(4): 343-347 (2018).
51. S. Chi, X. Liu, J. Wu, Q. Feng, L. Wang, J. Li, and T. Sun. Preparation of polyvinyl alcohol/ sodium alginate/ Artemisia sphaerocephala Krasch gum hydrogels with excellent water absorption and its application in the preservation of Lateolabrax Japonicus fillets. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 308: 141824 (2025).
52. D. Damat, R.H. Setyobudi, P. Soni, A. Tain, H. Handjani and U. Chasanah. Modified arrowroot starch and glucomannan for preserving physicochemical properties of sweet bread. Ciência e Agrotecnologia. 44: e014820 (2020).
53. R.H. Setyobudi, D. Damat, S. Anwar, A. Fauzi, T.Liwang, L. Zalizar, Y.A. Nugroho, M. Wedyan, M. Setiawan, S. Husen, D. Hermayanti, T.D.N. Subchi, P.G. Adinurani, E.D. Septia, D. Mariyam, I.R. Utarid, I. Ekawati, R. Tonda, E.D. Purbajanti, S. Suherman, M.S. Susanti, T.A. Pakarti, I. Iswahyudi, B. A. Prahardika, and A.R. Farzana. Amino acid profiles of coffee cherry flour from different origins: A comparative approach. E3S Web of Conference 432: 00032 (2023).
54. S. Shankar, F. Danneels, and M. Lacroix. Coating with alginate containing a mixture of essential oils and citrus extract in combination with ozonation or gamma irradiation increased the shelf life of Merluccius sp. fillets. Food Packaging and Shelf Life 22: 100434 (2019).
55. D. Behsnilian and E. Mayer-Miebach. Impact of blanching, freezing and frozen storage on the carotenoid profile of carrot slices (Daucus carota L. cv. Nutri Red). Food Control 73: 761-767 (2017).
56. Damat D, Setyobudi RH, Harini N, Asmawati A, Anwar S, Mahesah CZ , Wachid M, Andoko E, and Salsabila AT. Characteristics of gluten free biscuit from purple sweet flour, rice brands and coffee cherry flour. E3S Web of Conference 432: 0008 (2023).
57. K.A.T. Castillo-Israel, K.J.D. Sartagoda, M.C.R. Ilano, L.E.L. Flandez, M.C.M. Compendio, and D.B. Morales, Antioxidant properties of philippine bignay (Antidesma bunius (Linn.) spreng cv. ‘Common’) flesh and seeds as affected by fruit maturity and heat treatment. Food Research 4(6): 1098-1987 (2020).
58. B. Ryu, K.H. Shin, and S.K. Kim. Muscle protein hydrolysates and amino acid composition in fish. Marine Drugs 19(7): 377 (2021).
59. W. Fan, X. Tan, M. Tu, F. Jin, Z. Wang, C. Yu, L. Qi, and M. Du. Preparation of the rainbow trout bone peptides directed by nutritional properties and flavor analyses. Food Science and Nutrition 6(4): 925-933 (2018).
60. G.D.M.P. Madhusankha and R.C.N. Thilakarathna, Meat tenderization mechanism and the impact of plant exogenous proteases: A review. Arabian Journal of Chemistry 14(2): 102967 (2021).
61. K.I. Jeyasanta, and J. Patterson. Nutritive evaluation of trash fishes in tuticorin ( India ). World Journal of Fish and Marine Sciences 6(3): 275-288 (2014).
62. T. Imaizumi, F. Tanaka, and T. Uchino. Effects of mild heating treatment on texture degradation and peroxidase inactivation of carrot under pasteurization conditions. Journal of Food Engineering 257: 19-25 (2019).
63. Q. Wu, H. Xiang, S. Hao, J. Cen, Sh. Chen, Y. Zhao, Ch. Li, H. Huang, and Y. Wei. Quality changes and deterioration mechanisms during frozen storage of starching tilapia fillets based on quality characteristics, protein properties and microstructure analysis. Food Chemistry 487: 144265 (2025)
64. S. N. Hussin, A. Azlan, H.E. Khoo, N.A.A. Abdul Kadir, and M.R. Razman. Comparison of fat composition and chemical properties of fat extracts between fish fillets of selected warm-water and cold-water fish. Bioscience Journal 35(6): 1968-1978 (2019).
65. M.E. Haque, M.J. Gollock, and A.M. Salter. Fatty acid composition, moisture and lipid content of hybrid catfish (Clarias gariepinus × Heterobranchus longifilis) fillets at different weight categories. Foods 12(5): 12051112 (2023).
66. Q.H. Alhamadany, A.T. Yaseen, A.T. Yasser, and A.W. Ali. Chemical and mineral composition of ten ecomonically important fish species in the satt Al-Arab river and Iraqi marine water northern west arabian gulf,. Iraqi Journal of Agricultural Sciences 52(3): 632-639 (2021).
67. L.N. Murthy, G.G. Phadke, A. Jeyakumari, and C.N. Ravishankar. Effect of added calcium and heat setting on gel forming and functional properties of Sardinella fimbriata surimi. Journal of Food Science and Technology 58: 427-436 (2020).
68. N. Tsighe, M. Wawire, A. Bereket, S. Karimi, and I. Wainaina. Physicochemical and microbiological characteristics of fresh Indian mackerel, spotted sardine and yellowtail scad, from eritrea red sea waters. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis 70: 98-104 (2018).
69. D. Ikasari, S. Suryanti, and T.D. Suryaningrum. Proximate composition and sensory characteristics of traditional and oven-drying smoked tilapia fillets enriched with olive oil. Squalen Bulletin of Marine and Fisheries Postharvest and Biotechnology 12(3): 127-137 (2017).
70. S.M. Azam and M. Naeem. Proximate body composition of talang queenfish (Scomberoides commersonnianus Lacépède, 1801) from Pakistan. Sarhad Journal of Agriculture 38(1): 204-209 (2022).
71. I. Chwastowska-Siwiecka, N. Skiepko, J.F. Pomianowski, M.S. Kubiak, M. Woźniak, and M. Baryczka. Gender differences in the chemical composition and selected properties of African Catfish (Clarias gariepinus Burchell, 1822) Meat, Italian Journal of Food Science 28(3): 391-401 (2016).
72. M. Qubay, M.R. Vegi, and E. Mutegoa. Proximate composition and mineral content of the common fish species in the selected lakes of Tanzania. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis 142: 107510 (2025).
73. R. Tonda, L. Zalizar, W. Widodo, R.H. Setyobudi, D.Hermawan, D. Damat, E.D. Purbajanti, H. Prasetyo, I. Ekawati, Y. Jani, J. Burlakovs, S.K. Wahono, C. Anam, T.A. Pakarti, M.S. Susanti, R. Mahnunin, A. Sutanto, D.K. Sari, H. Hilda, A. Fauzi, W. Wirawan, NS. Sebayang, H. Hadinoto, E.Suhesti, U. Amri, and Y. Busa. Potential utilization of dried rice leftover of household organic waste for poultry functional feed. Jordan Journal of Biological Sciences 15(5): 879-886 (2022).
74. R. Hendroko, A. Wahyudi, S.K. Wahono, P.G. Adinurani, Salafudin, Salundik, and T. Liwang. Bio-refinery study in the crude jatropha oil process: co-digestion sludge of crude jatropha oil and capsule husk Jatropha curcas Linn. as biogas feedstocks. International Journal of Technology 4(3): 202-208 (2013).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Upon acceptance of an article, its copyright will be assigned to the Pakistan Academy of Sciences.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY). Allows users to: copy the article and distribute; abstracts, create extracts, and other revised versions, adaptations or derivative works of or from an article (such as a translation); include in a collective work (such as an anthology); and text or data mine the article. These uses are permitted even for commercial purposes, provided the user: includes a link to the license; indicates if changes were made; gives appropriate credit to the author(s) (with a link to the formal publication through the relevant DOI); and does not represent the author(s) as endorsing the adaptation of the article or modify the article in such a way as to damage the authors' honor or reputation.
